Fix Gents Chain?

February 10th, 2014
contra
In contra dance there's a common move "ladies chain". Danced traditionally it looks something like this, though more commonly people will put in a twirl. As it's one of the few figures in contra dance that is done from one gender position but not the other, people have tried to make a gender-reversed version. There were basically two ways this could have gone:
  • Mirror image: gents start on the left, pull by left, reverse courtesy turn.
  • Gender swap: gents start on the right, pull by right, courtesy turn.
Someone picked the mirror version [1] and that's what has spread as the definition. But I think it would have been much better the other way around. Pulling by with the left hand is fine; the problem is with the backwards courtesy turn. There's nothing fundamentally wrong with it, but like a backwards swing or driving on the wrong side of the road it feels off.

It's possible that if I had never danced a ladies chain as a lady I wouldn't see a problem with the gents chain, but lots of people dance both roles so many people are in this position. As it is I dislike the figure enough that I wish people would stop calling it, but perhaps we could fix it and do it the other way?


[1] Modern contra dance history is all recent enough that this person may well be known, and is perhaps even on facebook. Who was it? Own up!

Comment via: google plus, facebook, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

LLMs roleplay characters

I. I’m going to talk about the persona selection model, which in my opinion is one of the most important concepts to understand if you want to understand large language models’ psychology.

via Thing of Things May 1, 2026

You should try contra dancing

a story of middle school Ben • a not-very-illuminating description of the mechanics • flow, joy, and community • the antidote to the rest of life • how to try contra

via benkuhn.net April 24, 2026

On AI writing in 2026

I use AI to write a little bit: I ask it for high level feedback on blog post drafts, make mechanical edits, and sometimes use it to brainstorm options for wording at a paragraph level. It’s unusual that I accept its wording or changes without modificatio…

via Home April 16, 2026

more     (via openring)