Significant Whitespace In Expressions

January 8th, 2011
ideas, math, programming, tech
Order of operations can conflict with what an expression looks like it should mean. For example, the expression a * b+c looks like it means a*(b+c) but technically (and in most computer languages) means (a*b)+c. This seems analagous to the reasoning behind python using indentation instead of braces. The C code:
  if (x)
     if (y)
       z();
  else
     w();
looks like it should mean
  if (x) {
    if (y) {
      z();
    }
  }
  else {
    w();
  }
but actually means
  if (x) {
    if (y) {
       z();
    }
    else {
      w();
    }
  }
Python deals with this by treating the whitespace as significant, so:
  if x:
    if y:
      z()
    else:
      w()
and
  if x:
    if y:
       z()
  else:
    w()
both mean what they look like they should mean.

Some examples of how I would propose we do things instead:

  write                 to mean
  -----                 -------
  a+b                   a+b
  a + b*c               a+(b*c)
  a * b+c               a*(b+c)
  a+b * c+d             (a+b)*(c+d)
  a+b - c+d             (a+b)-(c+d)
  a+b  *  c+d - e+f     (a+b) * ((c+d) - (e+f))
  a  *  c + d + e       a*(c+d+e)
  a + b                 a+b, maybe yields warning
  a-b+c                 error
  a*b+c                 error
Algorithm:
for each number of spaces 0 on up:
  group any terms with that number of internal
  spaces by adding parens

Comment via: facebook

Recent posts on blogs I like:

Against Lyman Stone On Animal Welfare

Demographer Lyman Stone writes:

via Thing of Things March 21, 2025

Product in the age of AI

We’re seeing AI features pop up in every product we use. Slack, Google Drive, etc.

via Home March 18, 2025

How I've run major projects

focus • maintain a detailed plan for victory • run a fast OODA loop • overcommunicate • break off subprojects • have fun • bonus content: my project management starter kit

via benkuhn.net March 16, 2025

more     (via openring)