Magical Healing Powers

August 11th, 2012
stupid_posts
Imagine you had magical healing powers. Sitting quietly with someone and holding their hand you could restore them to health. While this would be a wonderful ability to have, it would also be a hard one: any time you spent on something other than healing people would mean unnecessary suffering. How could you justify a pleasant dinner with your family or a relaxing weekend at the beach when that meant more people living in pain?

But you already have these powers. Through the magic of effective charity you can donate money to help people right now. The tradeoff remains: time you give yourself when you could be working means money you don't earn which then can't go to help the people who would most benefit from it.

(I don't think this means you should try for complete selflessness; you need to balance your needs against others'. But the balance should probably be a lot further towards others' than it currently is.)

Update 2012-08-12: this is a response to hearing people offline saying that if they had magical "help other people" powers then they should spend lots of time using them, without having considered that they already have non-magical "help other people" powers

Comment via: google plus, facebook, lesswrong, substack

Recent posts on blogs I like:

I did a meditation and it sort of changed my personality?!

a trip report

via benkuhn.net November 8, 2026

The bad part about rape is all the rape

I have recently seen a lot of people casually refer to consensual non-consent orgies as “rape orgies”.

via Thing of Things November 6, 2026

Test/verification technique effectiveness with Astra

When we looked at how well agents used test/verification techniques in August1, we saw that GPT-5.6 Sol generally did what you might call a caricature of various techniques when asked to use a technique or library such as TDD, QuickCheck, Lean 4, etc.; no…

via Posts on November 2, 2026

more     (via openring)