I decided to start offering her "silly time", which was 5-10min of playing together after she was fully ready for bed. If she wanted silly time she needed to move promptly through the routine, and being silly together was more fun than what she'd been doing.
This worked well, and we would play a range of games:
The impact to local businesses is not the only issue people raise, however, and I wanted to get a better overall understanding of how people view it. I went over the thousands of comments on the posts (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16) over the last six months, and categorized the objections I saw. Overall I found comments by 90 different people opposed to the proposal, and ignoring super short ones ("Stupid idea", "Oh no") I put them in 11 different categories. I counted some comments towards multiple categories: the goal was to understand how many people hold each objection. Here are the objections, sorted by the number of unique people raising each, and with some representative quotes:
Weekend | Camp | |
---|---|---|
Timing | Friday evening through Sunday afternoon | Full week |
Location | Urban | Rural |
Activities | Almost entirely social dancing | Mix of workshops, classes, social dancing, nature |
Schedule | Tightly packed | Relaxed |
Meals | Local restaurants and packed lunches | On-site together |
Housing | Hotels and staying with friends | On-site together |
Nearby I have Beantown Stomp and American Dance and Music Week at Pinewoods, as pretty typical examples.
A weirder difference, however, is that while weekends book bands, camps often advertise as if they are booking individual musicians even when they're booking bands. For example:
One part that jumped out at me, though, is his third point:
3) Real World Compensation is BehindRisking some generalizing and over-simplifying, any dance performer could tell you that over the past 10 (20!) years, the compensation numbers have been sticky, sometimes static. In real terms, compensation on the whole has not kept up with inflation.
This is quite important: if pay is decreasing in real terms then it's likely that the dance community is partly coasting off of past investment in talent and we shouldn't expect that to continue. Except when I look back over my own compensation, however, I don't see a decrease. For dance weekends, counting only weekends that included travel, my averages have been (in constant January 2025 dollars):
Work | Nucleic Acid Observatory | |
Work | Speaking | |
Band | Kingfisher | |
Band | Free Raisins | |
Band | Dandelion | |
Code | Whistle Synth | |
Code | Apartment Price Map | |
Board | BIDA Contra | |
Board | Giving What We Can | |
Spouse | Julia | |
Child | Lily | |
Child | Anna | |
Child | Nora |